Challenges In Energy Storage Systems For Power Generation.

Renewable Energy Sources and Energy Storage Systems

Nowadays, fossil fuels are one of the most widely used energy resource in this world. The global energy mix approach is becoming very complex nowadays, as both the suppliers and the consumers are considering different alternative environment friendly source of energy resource. The factors those are forcing the specified consideration includes: 

(a) The constantly enhancing need for the electric power both by the developed as well as developing countries

(b) Lack of resources for building power plants and also distribution networks in many developing countries

(c) Insufficiency in the power generation is facing by some of the industrialized countries

(d) Concern with the climate changes and emission of greenhouse gases

 For the future power generation systems certain renewable energy resources like renewable turbines, photovoltaic solar systems, solar-thermo power, biomass power plants, fuel cells, gas micro-turbines, hydropower turbines, combined heat and power micro-turbines and hybrid power systems are available. Due to the irregularity and variable nature, though the presences of exploitation of the Renewable Energy Sources (RES) are available but still for this reason only problems might rise. 

In addition to this, certain sudden momentary dips could occur due to renewable fluctuations, lightning strikes, sudden change of a load, or the occurrence of a line fault in system voltage. However, the earlier studies have determined that energy storage can recompense due to the stochastic nature of the system. Due to sudden deficiencies of RESs mainly for the short time periods without suffering any sort of loss for the load events might be indicated. Startups of more and more plant generation are not required for this application. Another issue is the integration of RESs into grids especially at the remote points, integration of RES in the grid are another issues that have been identified. For the extreme level of power fluctuation the unacceptable voltage might varies wherever the grid is defined to be weak.

In a power system with abundant hydro generation renewable power balancing is achieved quite economically. During the period of high power generation when load demand can be met by renewable power generation alone, hydro units can be shutdown and water stored in the upper reservoir. This stored water can be used to generate electricity and to meet the load demand during the period of low power generation. However, there is a limitation due to the stochastic nature of river inflow. The extent to which a hydro plant can effectively balance the renewable power variation usually depends on its storage capacity and river inflow. In a power system dominated by thermal power generation, renewable integration is a problem due to the ramping rate limitation on the thermal generators. Even when there is abundant renewable power, the thermal generators may at times have to be operated at a non-optimal operating point which makes it uneconomical. Pumped Hydroelectric Energy Storage (PHES) facilities have been considered an attractive alternative for load balancing and energy storage. They can provide ancillary services at high ramp rates, and they can also provide benefits from intraday energy price variation by releasing energy at high demand periods and buying energy at off-peak periods to pump water into the upper reservoir.

Hydroelectric Energy Storage and Load Balancing

From the current status it has been found that there are various drivers those are emerging and will spur growth in

The current status demonstrates that few drivers are developing nowadays and for the energy storage system the spur growth is increasing rapidly. Nevertheless huge number of  issues in regards to the ideal dynamic coordination (operational, specialized and market) of these rising vitality stockpiling advancements into the electric network are as yet not created and should be concentrated, tried and institutionalized are identified accordingly. These components include the development of stochastic generation from sustainable energy resources; an undeniably stressed transmission framework as new lines linger behind request; the development of small scale lattices as a component of conveyed network engineering; and the expanded requirement for unwavering quality and security in power supply [10]. The reconciliation of vitality stockpiling frameworks (ESSs) and further advancement of vitality changing over units (ECUs) incorporating sustainable power sources in the modern countries must be founded on the current electric supply framework foundation. This leads frequently to a top-down arranging technique. In this system, the arranging skyline is subdivided in long-, medium-and here and now arranging assignment. Due to that, a multi-dimensional mix undertaking in regards to the ideal coordination of vitality stockpiling frameworks will come about. In the ordinary joining and operation arranging procedure of mass power plants, typically a top-down system, originating from a general vitality utilization perspective down to a stepwise point by point depiction is utilized. The circumspection of the time scale in each arranging venture is a trade off amongst exactness and the quantity of specialized and efficient limits. This arranging system is basically determined by practical thought in a unidirectional electrical power store network. This implies the point by point precision of the model inside of each arranging stage (long, medium, here and now, dynamic) characterizes the ideal format of those regular supply frameworks.

On account of disseminated era the specialized limits are at first more essential for the arranging procedure to get a conservative ideal supply design under stable operation conditions. At the point when this is not thought about in the principal arranging steps, it can regularly prompt a contention potential between the vitality provider and the administrator/financial specialist of ECSs, particularly the ones in light of Renewable Energy Sources (RESs). Hence, the need emerges for arranging and reconciliation methodology which as of now incorporates clear details and meanings of the framework innate in front line. This implies, the procedure of framework demonstrating and organizing for ideal coordination of Energy Storage Systems and Distributed Energy Resources should as of now incorporate ESS and DER control capacities, cutoff points and limits. These necessities prompt Bottom-up technique beginning from decentralized (disseminated) era up to the brought together ordinary electrical supply framework. With Bottom-up methodology clear meaning of supply and control usefulness between ESS, DER and the electrical network can be determined. In light of these quick changes fast and general execution procedure for vitality stockpiling frameworks in mix with DERs into the electric lattice is the primary arranging assignment sooner rather than later. This is additionally expected to beat the present hole between the R and D exercises of ESS advancement and the framework joining process. This will drive too the ESS accessibility and make the R&D procedure of those sorts of new lattice components more compelling.

Drivers of Growth for Energy Storage Systems

Grid reliability is referred to as one of the most essential electric power system in our nation. Based on the electric demand, the Grid reliability acts as a real time match of electric generation.  Due to the absence of shelf life, this particular match cannot be achieved very easily. This match is possible on the time of requirement as the requirement in terms of electric demand keep on changes. The demand is measured to be highest in the daytime and on the night the demand get reduced.  

The major challenges faced by the Pump Hydro Storage Technique/System are as follows:

It has been recognized that the role of domestic power grid is played by the energy security role pumped storage. It is capable to reserve and control the Pumped storage hydropower that provides energy-balancing, stability, storage capacity, and ancillary grid services like the network frequency. This is possible due to the working ability of Pump storage plant in terms of r hydroelectric plants for giving respond to potentially large electrical load that might change within few seconds. In order to maintain the balance in the load system pump storage is used by the system developers. For increasing the efficiency of operation at the peak, this system enables large thermal generating sources and nuclear also.

Mainly for the low impact pump storages, like the off channel rather closed loop projects, processing and establishment of alternative as well as streamlined licensing are needed. Different pump storage developers nowadays are facing major environmental misconceptions. However, in previous days all most each of the operating pumped storages needs at least one main stem river alongside dam must be constructed. It helps to increase the awareness among the system developers, while measuring the impact from the large dam construction and storage reservoirs over the existing river system.

A new project has been developed which implies that, significant level of post construction are required to be developed by the system developers for mitigating the issues associated to power consumption and construction development. The system developers might associate themselves directly or indirectly to the project. In order to minimize the issues different pumped storage development communities has been evolved to improve the condition of the project.

A fairly new approach for creating pumped capacity project is to find the stores in territories those are physically isolated from existing waterway frameworks. These tasks are named "shut circle" pumped capacity, since they exhibit insignificant to no effect to existing stream frameworks. After the underlying filling of the stores, the main extra water prerequisite is negligible operational make-up water required to counterbalance dissipation or drainage misfortune. By abstention from existing complex oceanic frameworks altogether, these sorts of activities can possibly rather extraordinarily decrease the most notable sea-going effects hose are related with extend advancement.

In order to facilitate a vitality showcase structure where transmission suppliers advantage from long term concurrences with vitality storeroom engineers are available. Vitality stockpiling advances can give parts of transmission resources alongside their capacity in order to supply auxiliary administrations and reduce blockage by absorbing abundance period. Market runs for the most part restrict transmission resources from taking an interest in discount vitality and subordinate administration markets to keep up the autonomy of framework administrators and evade the potential for showcase control, regardless of whether genuine or saw

Planning and Integration

Unavailability of Market items that enable adaptable assets to give benefits that assistance meet electric framework necessities, including by quickly reacting frameworks that give basic limit including key vitality requiring periods. In today's electric market, pumped capacity can possibly bring included an incentive through subordinate administrations, past time-move of vitality conveyance. In any case, an absence of a national vitality strategy may prompt changing autonomous framework administrators (ISO) advertise guidelines and item definitions that may significantly affect the estimation of auxiliary administrations, including those identified with vitality stockpiling

Another critical test confronting pumped capacity extends the design and designers as well. It is the administrative course of events for advancement of new tasks. Moreover, a three-to five-year development period is regular for most substantial undertakings; besides, naturally kindhearted project being created to bolster sustainable power source joining could take six to ten years or longer to build. Hugh amount of money related establishments will back these sorts of long-lead extend through the authorizing time period.

Currently, the variable and sustainable power source extends those depend on essential wind and sunlight based advances have accomplished exceptionally solid rate of force in the reaction to the great expense. The condition may turn out to be regularly inadequate in light of the fact that the request of purchasers fluctuates with the changing time period. For giving the framework extraordinary level of firm quality and flexibility all the more fundamentally the firming assets must be worked precisely.

The carbon based period could be adversely affected with the social inclination that is fundamental for the vitality without the conceivably destructive feeling. For the framework stores like firming assets these specific assets upgrades the necessity in like manner. It has been discovered that, as the capacity of accessible firming assets touch as far as possible, for the strengthen variable of sustainable power source assets, the electric grid has turned towards the development of new flammable gas top plants. It took place because of the fleeting handling power and a lower cost of fuel. Because of the upgraded fleet of petroleum gas top plant, the non-used office and capacity will exceed the normal resultant.

Different issues occur as the system operates at insufficient partial load. The system will remain flexible even if the demand for the power is not much higher. For the electric grid operation due to the presence of extreme level of electricity, certain region of Pacific Northwest or southwest is negatively impacted. This particular condition is applicable for the variable as well as renewable energy. The requirement for conventional reserve generation capacity that is supported by the goal of 20-30% renewable resource generation could be deduced significantly for the bulk storages like pumped storage hydropower. It is expected that this could become possible within upcoming 5 to 6 six years expected within 2020. There is no such particular regulatory mechanism or market level price or incentive is present. Due to the deregulation of electric industry, no such regularity mechanism or marketing principle is present for this construction though these are required for new generation, energy storage, and transmission. Three different components of renewable resources are present such as new generation, energy storage, and transmission. For co-ordination and long term systems planning these components are strictly required.  While transmitting the system, major challenges in the energy generation are identified. These challenges are required to be mitigated sooner to make the system efficient in the desired location. Due to the bulk storage these challenges might took place. However, this bulk storage has the ability to mitigate some of these identified challenges by promoting and developing new renewable energy generation abilities. The value of the project will increase if the issues associated to the project get reduced. 

Bottom-Up Approach

According to Rehman, Al-Hadhrami and Alam (2015), the pumped hydroelectric storage is used and developed for storing the energy (renewable and non-renewable type) for electric power systems and it is helpful for load balancing. The hydroelectric energy storage is stored in form of the gravitational potential energy within the water that is pumped for elevating the water level in reservoir to a higher level. The benefits of using pumped hydroelectric storage are given below,

Low Cost Energy Storage: As explained by Ma, Yang and Lu (2014), the pumped hydroelectric storage has low cost energy storage system and it helps in developing the smarter functioning of the electric storage. The revenue generation of the system is increased by the supply of the more electricity at the periods of high demands.

Surplus Energy Storage: The main benefit of using pumped hydroelectric storage is that it is able to store the water released from the high power turbines (Foley et al. 2015). The intermittent sources such as wind or solar and the load base source such as coal or nuclear generates huge amount of energy. The excess energy from these sources could be stored in pumped hydroelectric storage for making it available for use in later time.

However, Beevers et al. (2015) have pointed out that the pumped hydroelectric storage has some drawbacks too such as losses of the pumping process and storage of reservoirs being small. They have been explained below,

Loss of energy: The loss of energy in pumped hydroelectric storage occurs during the pumping process (Zhang et al. 2016). The low off peak current is used for gaining the power to operate the system. The energy is used for powering the pumping process that is being utilized for developing the sufficient operation of the pumped hydroelectric storage. The energy lost is formed for developing the supplementary operation of the electricity storage.

Small storage or reservoirs: According to Barbour et al. (2016), the reservoir has small capacity to store the supplementary amount of the power and energy. The energy storage developed for assisting the pumped hydroelectric storage is of limited capacity and it would not be able to store surplus amount of electric power generation.

References

Barbour, E., Wilson, I.G., Radcliffe, J., Ding, Y. and Li, Y., 2016. A review of pumped hydro energy storage development in significant international electricity markets. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 61, pp.421-432.

Beevers, D., Branchini, L., Orlandini, V., De Pascale, A. and Perez-Blanco, H., 2015. Pumped hydro storage plants with improved operational flexibility using constant speed Francis runners. Applied Energy, 137, pp.629-637.

Foley, A.M., Leahy, P.G., Li, K., McKeogh, E.J. and Morrison, A.P., 2015. A long-term analysis of pumped hydro storage to firm wind power. Applied Energy, 137, pp.638-648.

Ma, T., Yang, H. and Lu, L., 2014. Feasibility study and economic analysis of pumped hydro storage and battery storage for a renewable energy powered island. Energy Conversion and Management, 79, pp.387-397.

Rehman, S., Al-Hadhrami, L.M. and Alam, M.M., 2015. Pumped hydro energy storage system: A technological review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 44, pp.586-598.

Zhang, N., Lu, X., McElroy, M.B., Nielsen, C.P., Chen, X., Deng, Y. and Kang, C., 2016. Reducing curtailment of wind electricity in China by employing electric boilers for heat and pumped hydro for energy storage. Applied Energy, 184, pp.987-994. 

Challenges with Grid Reliability

 Grid Frequency Support implies genuine power given to the electrical distribution grid to diminish any sudden, vast load unbalances so as to keep the framework recurrence inside the admissible  tolerance for a time period of 30 minutes.

Grid Angular Statbility implies decreasing oscillation powwr (because of quick occurences) by infusion and retention of genuine power.

Load Leveling is rescheduling of sure loads to cut the demand of the electrical power, or the creation of energy amid off-peak periods for storing it and using it amid peak demand periods. Peak Shaving is lessening electric use amid peak hours or moving utilization from the period of peak request to off peak periods.

Spinning Reserve is characterized as the measure of generation capacity that can be utilized to deliver power over a given duration which has not yet been focused on the creation of vitality within this period.

Power Quality is fundamentally identified with the adjustments in magnitude and the voltage shape and current. This gives rise to various issues including: Harmonics, Power Factor, Transients, Flicker, Sag and Swell, and so on. PHES can provide the solutions to these problems.

Power Reliability Can be displayed as the percentage/ratio of intrusion in conveyance of electric power (may incorporate surpassing the threshold and not just total loss of energy) versus add up to uptime. Pumped Hydro capacity frameworks can help in providing solid electric administration to purchasers.

Ride Through means the electric unit remains associated amid framework unsettling influence (voltage list). ESSs have the capability of giving energy to ride-through.

Unbalanced Load Compensation

This should be possible in combination with four-wire inverters and furthermore by infusing and retaining power independently at each phase to supply uneven loads.

The reduction in the cost of the electric storages can bring a great deal of change in the electric power systems.

This would also result in the resolution of the problems that are related to the Peak Load, improvement of the electric stability can be attained, and also the elimination of the disturbances of the power quality can take place.

There would be various points of storage in the system.

The Energy storage system incorporating with the advanced power electronics provides various benefits in technical and financial field.

Modern pumped storage hydropower project costs can vary based on site-specific conditions such as site geology, water availability, access to the transmission grid, and overall construction cost. A feasible project site would include an approximate cost estimate range from $1,500/kilowatt (kW) to $2,500/kW, based on an estimated 1,000 MW sized project. Pumped storage technology has advanced significantly since its original introduction and now includes improved efficiencies with modern reversible pump-turbines, adjustable-speed pumped turbines  , new equipment controls such as static frequency converters and generator insulation systems, as well as improved underground tunneling construction methods and design capabilities. Overall, the pumping/generating cycle efficiency has increased pump-turbine generator efficiency by as much as 5% in the last 25 years, resulting in energy conversion or cycle efficiencies greater than 80%.

Globally, there are approximately 270 pumped storage plants either operating or under construction, representing a combined generating capacity of over 127,000 MW. Of these total installations, 36 units consist of adjustable-speed machines, 17 of which are currently in operation (totaling 3,569 MW) and 19 of which are under construction (totaling 4,558 MW). Adjustable -speed pump-turbines have been used since the early 1990s in Japan and the late 1990s in Europe. A main reason that adjustable speed pumped storage was developed in Japan in the early 1990’s was the realization that significant quantities of oil burned in combustion turbines could be reduced by shifting the responsibility for regulation to pumped storage plants. Another advantage of adjustable-speed units is the increase in overall unit efficiency due to the fact that the turbine can be operated at its peak efficiency point under all head conditions, resulting in increased energy generated on the order of 3% annually. The current AUSTRALIAN fleet of operating (singles speed ) pumped storage plants does not provide regulation in the pump mode because the pumping power is “fixed” – a project must pump in “blocks” of power. The number and magnitude of blocks is dependent on the number and size of the plant’s units. However, adjustable-speed pumped storage units, while similar to single speed units in most aspects, are able to modulate input pumping power for each unit and provide significant quantities of frequency regulation. This can be very attractive to project owners since regulation service prices are a valuable ancillary service. Another expanded new key ancillary service opportunity in  AUSTRALIA is the added need for load following and regulation (generally known as system reserves) at night to accommodate variable renewable energy inputs. In particular, the need for system reserves at night is increasing to ensure adequate grid stability with higher percentages of variable renewable energy generation, including the demand for energy absorption capabilities during periods of high wind generation during low load (demand) periods. In addition to energy absorption needs, with the increased amounts of variable renewable energy being supplied at night while load is decreasing, there is a complimentary greater need for load following and regulation services to accommodate the greater changes to net load on the system. It has been found that more than 180 sites are available those are suitable for the pumped hydro energy storage identified by South Australia. Based upon the future requirement of energy, the state looks for better security. The Australian renewable energy for an ANU –led feasibility study and for the aimed development, the agency is giving $449,000 support financial support. For the energy resources and for the project the researchers of ANU are also taking part effectively. The research and developed helped them to map possible short term off river pumped hydro energy storage. Within the energy grid, the large share of energy storage is found to be very much supportive.  

Pumped Hydro Storage Technique/System

More than 180 sites which are potentially suited for pumped hydro energy storage have been identified across South Australia, as the state looks for ways to better secure its future energy needs. The Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA) is providing $449,000 support for an ANU-led feasibility study, aiming to develop a nation-wide atlas of potential off-river pumped hydro storage sites. Researchers from ANU are also working to map potential short-term off-river pumped hydro energy storage (STORES) sites that could support a larger share of renewable energy in the grid. The store sites are the pairs of reservoirs, that consist of around 10 hectares for each, that are segmented by an height difference of around 300 and 900 meters, mainly in the hilly zones.  These are connected with a pipe along with the help of a pump and turbine also. The stores require lesser amount of water than the power those are generated from the fossil fuel. On the environment It had a minimum impact as the water is recycled within the small reservoirs.  

With the time-shift electric energy that is generated by the renewable the storage can be used. Whenever, the price of the power is found to be lower, the energy could be stored according to the demand. Thus, the energy can be used. There are two different conditions those are identified accordingly that include:

1. When both the demand and price for power is very high and
2. When the output generated from irregular renewable generation is too lower 

Whenever, the energy storage is used for reducing the electricity mainly for the end-user of the electric time grid is found to be very much high. In this time phase the reduced demand are absolutely possible. 

If storage reduces financial losses associated with power outages. This benefit is very end-user-specific and applies to

Commercial and industrial (C&I) customers, primarily those for which power outages cause moderate to significant losses.

It took place if the energy storage reduces the financial loss that is associated to the power quality anomalies. The Power quality anomalies are referred to as those parts of interest those can cause loads to go off-line. It might damage the electricity by using the equipment that could negatively affect the entire electricity system grid.

Arbitrage includes buy of cheap power accessible amid low request periods to charge the capacity plant, so that the low valued vitality can be utilized or sold at a later time when the cost for power is high.

For regions where the supply of electric era limit is tight, vitality stockpiling could be utilized to counterbalance the need to: a) buy and put in new era as well as b) "lease" era limit in the discount power commercial center.

It is well known that energy storage can provide several types of ancillary services. In short, these are what might be called support services used to keep the regional grid operating. Two more familiar ones are spinning reserve and load following.

It is possible that use of energy storage could improve the performance of the T&D system by giving the utilities the

The ability to increase energy transfer and stabilize voltage levels. Further, transmission access/congestion charges can be avoided because the energy storage is used.

Conclusion

Conclusion :

In the upcoming future of the identified utilities it has been fund that the optimal integration of the pumped Hydro energy storage is a very much important task. In order to develop the general as well as the integration strategy that is exceptionally flexible in nature are the main target. It helps to integrate the distributed energy storage system. The system is based on the benchmark of hardware and software platform. The focus is mainly on the medium to small storage that is installed closely along with the distributed energy resource. While comprising to the large Pumped Hydro energy storages, the small sized energy storage is referred to as the stepwise procedure. For the pumped Hydro energy it is necessary to develop certain essential standards of control strategies and management.  It is involved in the storage and grid side also. In order to act as an interface in between the energy storage and the electric grid, the active and advanced electronic converters are needed to be optimized and improved properly. In addition to this, the standard rapid planning and the supported strategies developed by the standard mathematical descriptions and the automation software based system are required to be developed properly.  These applications are based upon the bottom up analysis. This approach should lead towards the rapid planning and integration strategy within which the planned task is producing.  The automation platform includes storage behavior, power electronics, control functions, and operation modes, etc while developing a real system. Proper application f these approaches will solve most of the technical and economical planning issues accurately with integration and also will help to perform the tasks of Pumped Hydro Storage Systems.

An extensive review of pumped hydroelectric energy storage(PHES) systems is conducted, focusing on the existing technologies, practices, operation and maintenance, pros and cons, environmental aspects, and economics of using PHES systems to store energy produced by wind and solar photovoltaic power plants.It has been agreed by the scienti?c community that massive electricity storage is the critical technology for the renewable power, if it is to become a major source of base load despicable power. Among all existing storage technologies, PHES is the most suitable technology for small autonomous island grids and massive energy storage both technological maturity and economical compatibility over the lifespan of the project.  

References : 

[1] P.C. Ghosh , B. Emonts, H. Janßen, J. Mergel, D. Stolten. “Ten years of operational experience with a hydrogen-based renewable energy supply system”, Solar Energy 75, 2003, pp. 469–478

[2] A. Bilodeau, K. Agbossou. Control analysis of renewable energy system with hydrogen storage for residential applications, Journal of Power Sources, 2005.

[3] N.Hamsic, A.Schmelter, A.Mohd, E.Ortjohann, E.Schultze, A.Tuckey, J.Zimmermann. “Stabilising the Grid Voltage and Frequency in Isolated Power Systems Using a Flywheel Energy Storage System,” The Great Wall World Renewable Energy Forum , Beijing, China, October 2006

[4] E.Ortjohann, N.Hamsic , A.Schmelter , A.Mohd, J.Zimmermann, A.Tuckey, E.Schultze.Increasing Renewable Energy Penetration in Isolated Grids Using a Flywheel Energy Storage System, the first International Conference on Power Engineering, Energy and Electrical Drives (POWERENG,IEEE),Portugal, April 2007.

[5] European Renewable Energy Council, “Renewable energy in Europe: building Markets and capacity,” James and James science publishers, August 2004.

[6] “FP7 Research Priorities for the Renewable Energy Sector”, Bruxelles, EUREC Agency, March 2005.

[7] Melissa M, “Flywheel Energy Storage System: The current status and future prospect,” Trinity Power Corporation, February 2004, pp.8-11.

[8] A.Ruddell, G.Schönnenbeck, R.Jones, “Flywheel Energy Storage Systems,” Rutherford Appleton Lab, UK.

[9] H.Bindner, “Power Control for Wind Turbines in Weak Grids,” Risø National Lab, March 1999.

[10] James A. McDowall, “Status and Outlook of the Energy Storage Market,” PES 2007, Tampa, July 2007.

[11] Y. Rebours, D. Kirschen. ”What is spinning reserve?”, The University of Manchester ,Sept 2005.

[12] Grid 2030 - A National Vision for Electricity’s Second 100 Years , Based on the Results of the National Electric System Vision Meeting Washington, DC April 2-3, 2003 July 2003.

[13] James M. Eyer, Joseph J. Iannucci, Garth P. Corey. “Energy Storage Benefits and Market Analysis Handbook, “Sandia National Laboratories REPORT, SAND2004-6177, December 2004.

[14] Status of Electrical Energy Storage Systems, dti report, DG/DTI/00050/00/00, URN NUMBER 04/1878. 2004.

[15] Jason Makansi, Jeff Abboud. Energy Storage, The Missing Link in the Electricity Value Chain,” An ESC White Paper Published by the Energy Storage Council, May, 2002.

[16] Ibrahim H, et al. Energy storage systems—Characteristics and comparisons. Renew Sustain Energy Rev (2007),

doi:10.1016/j.rser.2007.01.023

[17]Alstom Power (2012), Internal Database for Equipment Performance.

[18]CAISO (2006), Isemonger, A.G., “The Competitive Procurement of Voltage Support” June 2006, White Paper.

[19]CAISO (2009), Discussion Paper Renewable Integration: Market and Product Review. July 2009, https://www.caiso.com/27cd/27cdeb8548450.pdf

[20] CAISO (2010), Market Issues & Performance 2009 Annual Report, Department of Market Monitoring, California Independent System Operator Corp. April 2010.

 [21]CEATI International (2011), The Hydroelectric Industry’s Role in Integrating Wind Energy, February 2011.